Skip to content

Scraps of positivity in lost season

I’m not normally one to dwell on season’s past, especially crap ones, but I had ten minutes and was toying with some thoughts around if there was actually anything positive to say at all about the last nine months.

We began the season being fed the tag line of ‘new team, new era’ which coupled with Andy Scott pushing the mantra of ‘action not words’ told us in hindsight all we needed to know of what a cycle of incompetence we were to expect.

The much vaulted pre-season tour of Marbella open to supporters and then the awkward overt on-field celebrations after we beat Leyton Orient only encouraged those that should know better!

Dean Holden started the season without a recognised target man, which was never addressed and we were suffering injuries and were hapless at the back well before he was sacked by text after he went all kamikaze in an effort to beat Oxford on my birthday in August.

Transfer deadline day was at the bequest of Andy Scott and in rolled Chem Campbell, Louie Watson, James Abankwah and Slobodan Tedic. To add insult to injury Scott then spearheaded the arrival of a new head coach.

Often ridiculed on Charlton Life, the hiring of Michael Appleton took underwhelmed to new levels of underwhelming. I wrote on his first day “I can’t believe in Michael Appleton because he brings nothing to believe in.”

Appleton could not address our defensive issues nor the habit of only performing piecemeal in games. Wigan away first half was one of the season’s highlights as May, Leaburn and CBT offered a glimpse of taking us to another level, but we were forced to hang on at the end for the win.

Portsmouth away was an anomaly, albeit anticipated by Addicks, and Appleton’s dreary press conference’s continued to feature his longing for the January transfer window, a solid two months away, which hardly you’d think engendered team morale.

Even Cray Valley scored against us, twice, and team performances became more and more prosaic, matching the personality of Appleton himself.

The cycle of mediocrity surrounded us like a stink bomb in a closet. Gillingham in the FA Cup was another cup embarrassment, but all the while Appleton was claiming some unbeaten league run, which were mostly draws. We never got out of that habit nor the one in which we defended like we were applying for the circus.

Leyton Orient away on Boxing Day, with the Addicks again backed by a big following, was the last straw for most.

Dire performances continued as Appleton finally got his transfer window wish and despite a large offer for Jonson Clarke-Harris being turned down by the player, seven players were signed.

However, another injury time goal conceded, which was becoming a joke in itself, at home to Northampton saw a further embarrassing defeat in what was a bear pit of a Valley atmosphere and Appleton was sacked straight after the final whistle.

I know. I am not doing particularly well on finding the positives, but the management team with a large influence I’d say from the ownership chose Nathan Jones as our next manager and this was in all probability the most positive I have felt as a Charlton fan for some years.

Jones brought about positive change, making us harder to beat and more competitive. He also decisively kept us out of an historical relegation battle.

We were still often poor in games though, if not lacking in spirit or desire, we just lacked being any good, quite frankly.

Jones worked that out early and now we wait.

There were few players that endeared themselves under three different managers. POTY Alfie May and George Dobson about the only two senior players. The whole mismanagement of Dobbo’s contract brought Andy Scott’s role even more under the spotlight.

The introduction of Daniel Kanu and Karoy Anderson to the first team were big pluses, and seemingly out of nowhere came Thierry Small, who was our best player during the final few months of the season.

Although I did enjoy the teasing performance of the 1st half away at Wigan, the long awaited win at Derby after 18 games without one was fantastic. Anderson’s goal being my most celebrated.

Before that the draw at Bolton in the early days of Jones’ stewardship gave us all a huge lift and the best home game was Barnsley.

Three of those games were against the top six, and you can chuck both Portsmouth games in as well to only show what another lost season this was.

7 Comments Post a comment
  1. Daggs's avatar
    Daggs #

    And now we wait.

    Jones did enough with a crap squad to save us from relegation, for which we’re all mightily grateful.

    He’s now begun the cull. He talks a good game but reality will hit when the team he has chosen, within the financial restrictions that will undoubtedly be placed upon him, turns out next season.

    There will be nowhere to hide, our success or failure will be on his shoulders. Is he really the Messiah or will he become another failed manager at CAFC.

    May 9, 2024
    • cliffb50's avatar
      cliffb50 #

      to quote Monty Python….”He’s not the Messiah, he’s just a very naughty boy !!”

      May 9, 2024
  2. Sussexmick's avatar

    Reflects my views exactly.

    I just hope my optimism for next season is not stripped away in the management of players out and in before we next kick a ball in anger 🤞

    May 9, 2024
  3. cliffb50's avatar
    cliffb50 #


    Thank you CA for your on point comments a out the past bad season.

    Scott needs to reflect carefully on his serious errors of judgement this past season and not repeat !!!!

    This summer is very very critical regarding new players and our quest to get out of league 1

    May 9, 2024
  4. ChicagoAddick's avatar

    Sussexmick – this has been a problem for years even going back to the Belgians. Like you I am desperately hoping for better and for Jones to drive recruitment.

    May 9, 2024
  5. Kev Spencer's avatar
    Kev Spencer #

    I’m still not sure why we still need Andy Scott, if we ever did. Surely Nathan Jones should be driving recruitment as he’s been appointed manager rather than coach, just hope AS doesn’t get in the way.

    May 9, 2024
  6. peterhearn09's avatar
    peterhearn09 #


    I agree with all that you wrote. But feel the likes of Kanu and Anderson being good technical players are good prospects for us still as would be expected some nouse and with experience plus physical strength. All this will come, but we must not next year rely too heavily on the two young men. Give them time to mature a bit. But I hear we are after a striker/forward well if so it must be to compliment Alfie May and not replace him. Listen to Curbs he and others including your goodself I believe say he play up front or just being as a number 10. On top of this is his overall work rate for the team. I just hope those that should know this – in fact do.

    May 9, 2024

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Chicago Addick

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading